Price: $58.88
(as of Mar 18, 2026 07:43:16 UTC – Details)
To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyzed reviews to verify trustworthiness.Learn more how customers reviews work on Amazon
Customers find these weight plates to be of good quality.
Customers find these weight plates to be a great value.
Customers find that the weight plates work as advertised, with one mentioning they can be used for other weight lifting activities.
Customers have mixed experiences with the weight plates' accuracy, with some finding them to be the right weight and accurate, while others report that they don't match their existing weights and are lighter than expected.
Customers have mixed opinions about the appearance of the weight plates, with some finding them decent-looking while others say they look terrible.
Customers have mixed opinions about the weight plates' handles.
Customers report issues with paint chipping on these weight plates, with one customer noting that the silver paint is flaking off like crazy.
Customers report that the weight plates have a smaller diameter than expected.
Top reviews from the United States
Reviewed in the United States on February 27, 2026
Reviewed in the United States on December 5, 2025
Reviewed in the United States on March 14, 2026
Was delivered without a box, just bare weights on my porch. They’re nice, but have scuffs and bad paint job on the letters. Overall I like them but can’t give it 5 stars.
Reviewed in the United States on January 2, 2026
These things are awesome. I love cast iron plates, but they are different than what is pictured. I ordered to dishes, but received the ones pictured. The handles are good though and I’m still happy with it. It adds variation to my plate collection, so it was a pleasant surprise. More than that, the handle made it easy to transfer the weights on and off barbells.
The paint on the lettering scuffs easily, but it does the job! Weight is accurate and they’ve been fun. I’d recommend these to just about any strength lifter.
Reviewed in the United States on December 11, 2025
Reviewed in the United States on October 14, 2025
This may have been the weirdest amazon order ever for me. I didn't get what I ordered, I didn't get all of my order, 1 of the 4 packages was lost, one was delivered to the wrong address, the ones that arrived were not what was represented in the listing, each weight was from a different series that the manufacturer offers (they don't match), and the 5's are all 4.5 pounds.
I make it a point not to mention the shipping and or damage in shipping in my reviews but this time I had to mention it even though I did not subtract any stars for it. The 3 stars is my rating of the product only.
I ordered 4 of the 10 pound and 4 of the 5 pound weights initially, I ordered the gray ones. I will review them separately because the quality is not the same between the 2 and I didn't get the grey that I ordered but rather the black 10's from this listing and the handle 5's from a different listing.
The black 10s were over all pretty good , they look decent and 3 were very close to 10 one was about 4 oz shy of 10. They are very thick ,just in case that matters to you. Maybe dont pay extra for the black ones and just order the grey? Or maybe if you order the black you will get the grey? Do you like surprises?
The 5's I ended up reordering these as some of the ones I paid for are on a magic journey in another state. I contacted amazon and they offered a refund and reship but it never happened so I re ordered. I reached out to customer service a second time, promised a refund but I am still waiting.
The 5's are 4.5 pounds. While that doesn't seem like much i dont like my weights to be inaccurate. It seems like they added the handle hole and didn't add back the metal they removed. They look good but are not 5 pounds. Good ego plates but not good if you compete in any way and need accuracy, or if you like to know how much is actually on your bar without subtracting for light plates. So for example if you use 4 of these it is 18 pounds. The appearance and finishing is very good on the 5's, the 10's are a little more shiny but it is not very noticeable.
In the pictures you see car wheel weights which I used to bring them to their proper weight. Not really ideal but I like having my weights correct. The plates are oily and you may want to clean them before use. I went a little extra there so the adhesive for the wheel weights would stick.
Note; I am a glutton for punishment and bought a set of handled 10's from this companys other listing showing the handled tens. I wanted them to be like the 5's they sent me from this order which were not what I ordered but wanted matching 10's as I find myself using these plates in lieu of dumbells frequently, for things like warming up shoulders, allowing me not to have small dumbells around. From their other listing I ordered the matching 10's and nervously waited for their arrival. Low and behold the wrong plates again but I paid more for them (see my full review if you like). I can only conclude that you should buy the cheapest plates that are advertised as you will get a grab bag of styles.
